Paso Robles winemaker Tobin James Shumrick is facing criminal charges from the San Luis Obispo County District Attorney’s Office for allegedly shooting the wheels of a neighbor’s golf cart and vandalizing his truck in an altercation last October.
Shumrick, the founder of Tobin James Cellars, is pleading not guilty to three charges: felony shooting at an occupied vehicle, misdemeanor vandalism, and misdemeanor hit-and-run.
According to the SLO County Sheriff’s Office, on Oct. 2, 41-year-old Gabriel Canaday was driving his golf cart on the winery property on Union Road when Shumrick—”attempting to disable the golf cart”—shot out its tires with a shotgun. Shumrick then caused intentional damage to Canaday’s truck, the criminal complaint states. No one was injured in the incidents.
SLO sheriff’s deputies were called to the property the next day, Oct. 3, and they arrested Shumrick after he reportedly admitted to the shooting.
“Deputies interviewed Shumrick, who claimed the victim [had] been trespassing numerous times on his winery property, resulting in numerous calls for service from the Sheriff’s Office over the past few months,” Sheriff’s spokesperson Tony Cipolla told New Times via email.
Shumrick posted $250,000 bail, and his preliminary hearing date in SLO County Superior Court is Feb. 25.
Jere Sullivan, an attorney for Tobin James Cellars, told New Times that the 62-year-old Shumrick’s actions were necessary and justified by self-defense.
He said that over a “frightening” period of several months, Canaday repeatedly trespassed on the winery property and harassed and intimidated its employees and patrons.
“The winery was the victim,” Sullivan contended.
SLO County law enforcement and court records show an extensive recent history between the 27-year-old winery and Canaday. Over a two-year period, the Sheriff’s Office received 43 calls for service to the two properties, which face one another across Union Road. The calls grew so routine that deputies started conducting “extra patrols” to the winery.
According to Tobin James Cellars, Canaday’s trespassing became a near daily occurrence in mid-2019 with his visits growing increasingly erratic and threatening. He scared employees—at times blocking them from leaving the parking lot with his car—made vague threats, fired weapons from his property, trespassed at night, and accused the winery of hiding members of his family.
“Everybody was terrified of this man,” Sullivan said. “There were employees who threatened to quit [and] employees who actually quit over this.”
Since April 2019, Canaday has also been arrested 18 times, according to the Sheriff’s Office, mostly on warrants for violating restraining orders and failing to appear in court. He is accused of harassing his ex-wife and threatening to kill a local man.
“Everyone was on notice,” Sullivan said. “The courts were on notice. The sheriffs were on notice. Mr. Canaday was out of control.”
In late October—after the shooting and Shumrick’s arrest—Tobin James Cellars filed for its own restraining order against Canaday to protect its 66 employees. The order was granted in court, but like the others, Canaday also allegedly violated it by texting winery staffers and continuing to trespass.
On Nov. 15, a sheriff’s deputy attempted to arrest Canaday at a traffic stop, but he fled down Highway 46 in his vehicle. After a chase, Canaday returned to his Union Road residence where he was finally apprehended with the help of a CHP helicopter.
In the wake of his arrest, Canaday was denied bail, and he underwent psychiatric evaluation. He was found to be competent for trial, and pleaded no contest to resisting arrest and evading an officer. On Jan. 28, a SLO County judge sentenced him to five months in county jail.
With Shumrick now facing the possibility of jail time for shooting at Canaday’s golf cart, Sullivan said he wished law enforcement had been “more proactive” as the neighbor-to-neighbor conflict escalated.
“There was no way of telling if this was going to be the time of crossing the line of committing violence,” Sullivan said. “You could see the potential was there.”
Sullivan said he’s confident of Shumrick’s innocence, as he said it constituted a “defense of property, defense of staff, and defense of clients.”
“All of the informal efforts and formal efforts to get him to stop failed,” Sullivan said. “It wouldn’t stop.” Δ
Assistant Editor Peter Johnson can be reached at pjohnson@newtimesslo.com.
This article appears in Jan 30 – Feb 9, 2020.
I know Toby and he’s hard to rile. This sounds like he was pushed to his limit.
You could say he went Ballistic!
Tell you what, someone trespasses on my property time and time again, harasses and threatens my family, friends, employees, and after multiple legal attempts of trying to unsuccessfully stop those actions, I’d have shot him, not just his golf cart. Any one of us would have. The dirt bag got what he deserved. Toby was more than patient and tried time and time again to peacefully resolve this problem. You can only be pushed into a corner so many times before you have to protect what matters and fight back. More power to you Toby, you deserve a huge high-five, certainly not jail time.
I cannot believe Toby is even being brought up on charges. This is ridiculous. County sheriffs ought to be ashamed, what DA would prosecute this?!
This is insane. Toby repeatedly tried to resolve this issue with the authorities, and with this nut job. Tobys not the bad guy here. Shame on the sheriffs😤😡I have known Toby for over 10 years he is a good man has a heart of gold, aLways caring and putting others first . He loves his family friends and his employees. They love working for him and never want to leave.
He’s doing what any Man would do is to protect his people. We love Toby and stand behind him 100%❤️
Lisa & Stan
I can’t believe this generous and kind soul has to go through this. I’m 100% sure it was justified. If the law would have done their job. It wouldn’t have come to this. I stand with Toby all the way.
wow! people need to realize there are some very sick but functional people out there and the sheriffs tool box is not equipped to handle them. When good citizens are forced to step up and protect themselves and those they care about that same law enforcement tool box turns against the victim and protects the abuser. its a very scary situation.😳
Clampdown. Do jackshit authorities ignore property owner rights. But God forbid the property owner protects himself, his property or others. This is a local government shakedown. They will fine him 10k for this, plus he’ll have to pay Jere another 10k. Pure bullshit.
Hi Tobin Jay. Or James.
I’ve got a young 2nd and a half Cousin Named Tobin James
Or is it
Trevor James Marks G. ?
Hey lil’ bro-? Are you still around?
It is Timothy – your Friend.and Big Brother.
I really like you guys.
Well I can’t say much . Butt I am in Coos Bay, Oregon 97420 USA.
How did he miss and shoot the tires? Dead men tell no tales. Should have dealt more firmly with the nut bar a lot earlier IMO.
Please arrest & put him away before we see this on Dateline. He’s not right & is going to end up killing someone!!
I worked in the tasting room during this and can say first hand that the neighbor is a wacko and was out of control. Toby did everything in his power to protect all of us. This man stalked the winery, the employees coming and going, the guests….he was scary. All my support to the Tobin James family….it is a fantastic winery and staff that have been through ridiculous stress because of this crazy neighbor.
Did anyone mention that Canaday’s wife and children were living with Tobin at the time?????? Canaday was still married to his wife. Oh poor Tobin. What’s the real story behind the story????? Find out before you comment on fluff news.
If a wife is trying to get away from her husband, why would she take the kids and move directly across the street in full view of him? Who’s nutso?