Autumn brought special concoctions like Apple Butter Swirl to Splendor’s counter. The sweet cream base is infused with spiced walnuts and homemade apple butter.
IT’S FALL Y’ALL Autumn brought special concoctions like Apple Butter Swirl to Splendor’s counter. The sweet cream base is infused with spiced walnuts and homemade apple butter. Credit: PHOTO BY MADISON WHITE

When carefully crafted, artisanal ice cream shops started trending, Jenny Packard would find herself waiting in line for a scoop. She lived in LA and new stores were popping up regularly.

Skip ahead to when Jenny was expecting her first child with her husband, Sean, in San Luis Obispo, and her fondness for ice cream had become a craving.

“We were both on the same page that we could use an ice cream shop in the neighborhood,” Jenny told New Times on a Thursday afternoon in November. “We love the Railroad District. It’s very quaint and historic and just has a great feel.”

A good day for ice cream
Visit Splendor Sunday to Thursday from noon to 9 p.m. and Friday to Saturday from noon to 10 p.m. The shop is located at 1000 Railroad Ave., unit 100, in San Luis Obispo. See more online at splendoricecream.com and on Instagram @splendoricecream. Call (805) 762-0222 with questions.

The Packards have owned Sally Loo’s Wholesome Café since 2017 and got the opportunity to expand into the space next door. While it wasn’t necessarily their dream to get into the ice cream business, Jenny knew that the hyper-local, seasonal philosophy behind Sally Loo’s would translate perfectly to the frozen treats.

In early November, Splendor hosted its first birthday party and invited the whole town. The team even made a special birthday cake limited edition flavor.

“I think overall we’ve had a really good response, so that’s encouraging,” Jenny said. “A lot of people are coming back pretty often. A lot of regulars.”

Menu items constantly change at Splendor, keeping up with the ingredients of the season.

“[There’s] just so much access to high-quality produce and products here, and I think that’s definitely part of SLO,” Sean said.

Unfortunately, there aren’t enough dairies to supply the shop, he added, so they source from Northern California.

When the ingredients make it to Splendor’s San Luis Obispo kitchen, milk, cream, and sugar are combined to make the ice cream base. Then the team infuses add-ins.

Four flavors make up the seasonal menu. For a dairy-free scoop, Splendor offers Coconut Cream Horchata with notes of toasted rice and cinnamon.

To celebrate one year of dishing out ice cream to neighbors near and far, Splendor served a limited-edition birthday cake flavor.
A SWEET NEW CHAPTER To celebrate one year of dishing out ice cream to neighbors near and far, Splendor served a limited-edition birthday cake flavor. Credit: PHOTO BY MADISON WHITE

Apple Butter Swirl mixes homemade spiced walnuts and apple butter. Not only are the seasonal options a hit among customers, but Splendor’s staff members enjoy them, too.

Team member Teagan Dees is especially enjoying Harvest Pumpkin, which blends pumpkin puree and cozy fall spices, according to the menu, and is as in-demand as ever this time of year.

Dees’ other favorite is Chocolate Ripple, featuring swirls of salted fudge.

The Cal Poly senior started working at Splendor in September. She said she’s excited for the next round of flavors to drop after Thanksgiving.

“I love the ice cream, obviously, but also just the people that work here, that come in here are all just great and super sweet,” Dees said.

She helps scoop singles and doubles for customers and hands out to-go pints and ice cream cakes. Sometimes, there’s still a discontinued flavor hiding in the cold case if the menu just changed.

Classic flavors remain on the board consistently, though. Jenny and Sean are both fans of Cacti Espresso and use decaf coffee from the local roaster. Other long-standing flavors include traditional sweet cream called The Pearl; the Beehive (plus its vegan companion Train Tracks) with homemade chocolate-coated honeycomb candy and peanut butter; and Sally’s Waffle with Splendor’s own almond butter.

The ice cream shop shares a kitchen with Sally Loo’s. Inside, team members are hard at work making toppings like cookies, brownies, waffles, and apple butter.

As far as the actual ice cream goes, Jenny said they’re making fresh batches about five days a week. Each flavor requires multiple days of preparation.

“We do fudge sauce, caramel sauce, also a few sundaes,” Jenny said. “We want to start doing seasonal sundaes, like a fruit compote.”

Customers choose from 12 flavors at Splendor, including enduring classics and rotating seasonal options. Pints and ice cream cakes are available to take home, too.
MAKE IT INTO A SHAKE Customers choose from 12 flavors at Splendor, including enduring classics and rotating seasonal options. Pints and ice cream cakes are available to take home, too. Credit: PHOTO BY MADISON WHITE

Also in the works are pre-orders for pecan and pumpkin pies ahead of the holidays with a pint of Splendor ice cream on the side. Pickup will likely be available a day or two before Thanksgiving.

“A lot of the same stuff, made here, and you’ll be able to get your ice cream with that,” Sean said.

He went to Cal Poly and started working as a civil engineer in the area. He married Jenny during the pandemic, quit his job, and started helping her full time with the café.

“In the meantime, the opportunity here came up, and we felt like things were going well enough that we could tackle this,” Sean said of Splendor.

They wanted to keep the feeling of the original building intact, he said, noting that he thinks it’s more than 100 years old.

The renovations took two years. Starting a project from scratch was a new undertaking for them. The couple planned to be done before their second child was born, but opening day turned out to be quite a bit later.

NO. 1 Beehive is one of the most popular picks at Splendor. It comes mixed with homemade chocolate-coated honeycomb candy and peanut butter swirls. There’s a dairy-free option called Train Tracks. Credit: PHOTO BY MADISON WHITE

“It was surreal to see the drawing on the computer screen, and then see it actually turn out in real life,” Sean explained.

Jenny exercised her creative vision for the project, wanting to bring a warm nostalgia to the inside. She said they had help from a great designer, too.

“People tell us it feels like Disneyland when they walk in here,” Jenny said. “We wanted something with color and wood and kind of like an old-school feel.”

The Packards are grateful to customers and to their close circle of support that helps them balance raising two young kids and owning two businesses.

“Hopefully the product speaks for itself but offers a special experience for locals, for visitors [to] leave not just feeling happier than when they came, but memorable too,” Sean said.

“I had the vision,” Jenny said. “I wanted to improve the neighborhood and offer just an experience, a great place people can enjoy.” ∆

Sun Staff Writer Madison White, from New Times’ sister paper, recommends the Apple Butter Swirl before it’s gone. Reach her at mwhite@santamariasun.com.

Local News: Committed to You, Fueled by Your Support.

Local news strengthens San Luis Obispo County. Help New Times continue delivering quality journalism with a contribution to our journalism fund today.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *