New Times / Cover Story
The following articles were printed from New Times [newtimesslo.com] - Volume 27, Issue 24
Let them competeVolunteers and the YMCA keep middle school sports alive in the wake of Paso Robles School District budget woes
By NICK POWELL
The parking lot at Daniel Lewis Middle School in Paso Robles was mostly empty on a recent cold and quiet morning, until a handyman’s truck pulled in and stopped briefly. The school was closed for winter break, and the driver wasn’t there to fix anything. A young boy got out and ran with sneakers in hand to the campus gym. Inside, upbeat music blaring on the public address system got kids in the mood to move, and more than a dozen adolescents dribbled, shot, and chased after basketballs, their shoes squeaking on the smooth gym floor.
If the facility were closed, most of the boys would have been asleep or sitting in front of a television with a big bowl of Honey Smacks while their parents went off to work, winter break or not.
And considering the Paso Robles Joint Unified School District’s budget, the gym should be closed.
According to a 2011 Grand Jury report, the district’s enrollment and corresponding state funding have been in decline since 2008. By 2011, the district reported a “negative financial certification” to the San Luis Obispo County Board of Education, meaning deficit spending would be unavoidable by 2012.
To stave off the inevitable, the district stopped funding middle school sports programs in 2009, but the San Luis Obispo YMCA was able to step in with 21st Century grants worth $250,000 and a transportation grant of $20,000. The money was divided between George Flamson and Daniel Lewis middle schools to pay for coaches, uniforms, equipment, and buses for their 20 sports teams, according to YMCA CEO Jenifer Rhynes. Track and field, volleyball, and basketball continued uninterrupted with few discernable changes for the boys and girls who competed. The YMCA performed background checks on potential coaches, cut their checks, processed registration forms, and shielded the schools from potential lawsuits with the organization’s million-dollar insurance policy, but the grants disappeared in July 2011 because they’re only offered to schools with at least 75 percent of the students receiving free or reduced cost lunches, and Paso’s middle schools no longer qualified. Rhynes said the YMCA will apply for the grant again in 2013, but “it’s not looking terribly hopeful.”
Still, kids fill the gyms year round to practice and compete, and coaches continue to show up, drill skills, and inspire kids to improve, despite the fact that they no longer get paid for their efforts. The district’s entire middle school sports program, which includes two different schools, four unique sports, and more than 20 teams divvied up by grade and gender, is run almost exclusively by volunteers. The only people getting paid for their participation are the referees, bus drivers, and janitors, but for the volunteers working directly with the kids, there’s more to be had from the experience than a paycheck.
“My father was an athletic director for 30 years. I guess it’s in my blood,” Paul Bodenshot said. “I’m blessed to wake up happy to go to work every day.”
Bodenshot teaches special education courses at Lewis Middle School, where he also coaches basketball and serves as the athletic director for all Paso Robles middle school sports. He held onto the positions even after the district stopped paying him for them, and it doesn’t seem likely that he’ll stop anytime soon.
“I don’t want middle school sports to die. It’s just so important,” Bodenshot said. “Middle school is a time for kids to figure themselves out. To get rid of sports would only reduce their options. It would limit their potential.”
His biggest reward comes when teams from the two Paso Robles middle schools compete against each other. Then, students come to cheer for their friends while supportive parents pack the stands, sell tickets, and work the snack bar. Games wouldn’t be possible without them, and seeing so many people come together and give their time in the spirit of competition reassures Bodenshot that his volunteer hours are well spent.
“It’s a lot of hours,” volleyball coach Sue Knupper said. “There’s practices and games, but there’s also all the little things—answering e-mails, making phone trees, hanging posters, scheduling. It adds up.”
Knupper estimated that her coaching duties add an extra two hours to her workday. She used to get a $1,600 stipend; now she gets nothing, but she loves working with young athletes, seeing the drive in their eyes. She said athletics help motivate kids to get better grades (they can’t play if they’ve got any Fs on the report card or a grade point average less than 2.0), and team sports develop their abilities to communicate and work together.
Before the budget cuts, the YMCA already offered after-school sports classes in the North County, meaning adolescents would have had some athletic opportunities even if school sports disappeared, but Knupper said that school sports add important elements of competition and team spirit that are especially beneficial to developing minds.
Dr. Jason Cohen, a local psychologist who specializes in sports therapy, echoed that sentiment. He noted that the middle school years, which cover the onset of puberty for most kids, are crucial in the formation of long-term habits. Young athletes, he said, exhibit higher degrees of life satisfaction and improved body images. Research published in the March 2012 edition of the Journal of Sports Sciences found that physically fit children outperformed their unfit counterparts in cognitive tests and even had significantly larger brain structures, especially in the basal ganglia, which allows people to choose appropriate behavioral responses to stressful situations.
“People want to divide mental and physical abilities, but that’s a divide we’ve created through perception, not one that exists in reality,” Cohen said.
Cohen said adolescent bodies need at least an hour of moderate to rigorous activity every day, but many kids aren’t getting that. According to the Center for Disease Control, the obesity rate among American adolescents surged from 5 percent in 1980 to 18 percent in 2008. In Cohen’s opinion, the decision makers who’ve cut district budgets and limited schools’ ability to focus on anything but the primary areas of academic achievement must be ignorant of research addressing the importance of physical activity. Any savings achieved through the elimination of sports programs will come back to bite society in the form of increased health care and law enforcement costs, Cohen said.
“Kids need to learn how to work together, how to set goals, how to fail,” Cohen said. “Sports teach all of those things.”
Unfortunately, sports don’t come cheap. Rhynes said that it costs roughly $300 per kid to organize and execute a season’s worth of games. Families are asked to pay a $90 participation fee, but that leaves a $210 difference.
Enter Debbie Caruana, Paso’s fundraising wonder woman.
Caruana first heard that the YMCA was stepping in to rescue middle school sports over Facebook, and she immediately decided to get involved, even though her children weren’t taking part in the threatened programs. Caruana’s sixth-grader wasn’t interested, but her high-school-age son had been involved in youth baseball for years, introducing Caruana to the North County athletic community. She said she couldn’t stand by and watch track and field, basketball, and volleyball disappear for adolescents.
“I didn’t even know schools had budgets when I was their age, but that’s all these kids hear about is budget cuts,” Caruana said. “It’s a shame. If we want to give them what we had, parents need to step up.”
She got together with other concerned parents and teachers for a brainstorming session, and they formed a booster group dubbed “the Middle Cats,” which would work to support the Flamson Cougars and the Lewis Leopards equally.
“I really enjoy watching it all come together,” Caruana said. “I wouldn’t do it if I didn’t enjoy it.”
With Caruana leading the effort, the Middle Cats recently organized a Halloween-themed dance, open to students from both schools and held at neutral territory: the Centennial Park Ballroom. She said parents enthusiastically volunteered to help out and that there was no trouble finding support in the community. Roughly 500 students and parents participated in some way or another, Caruana said.
The city let the group use the location at a discounted price (enough just to cover cleaning costs) and local businesses donated many of the supplies and refreshments. Fluid Silk Screening gave the group commemorative shirts that were sold during the dance, and Tobin James Winery donated boxes of candy for kids to buy between songs. The dance was a huge success, generating $5,000, Caruana said.
Another fundraiser is scheduled for Feb. 2. This one will be a “Super Fun Run” open to everyone—kids, adults, locals, and tourists—with professionally timed 10k, 5k, and shorter kids’ runs starting from the War Memorial Stadium at Flamson Middle School at 8 a.m. Participation costs $15 to $40, and more information can be found at superfunrun.org.
Caruana said fundraising has been so successful that the Middle Cats are optimistic about cutting participation fees in half in the near future, and eventually eliminating them altogether.
Shelly Dargatz, the YMCA’s North County regional director, said it would be impossible to keep the school sports programs running without the generous help of volunteers and donors, and such people have been easy to find. Knowing the value sports add to young lives, teachers, parents, and students have come together and stepped up to save the programs in the face of unending state budget reductions, she said.
“This could be done elsewhere,” Dargatz said. “This is hopefully a model for everyone.”
Staff Writer Nick Powell can be reached at .